Egregoros

Signal feed

Timeline

Post

Remote status

Context

24
I did a pretty deep dive on that question and what I found was they just blamed everything kings ate. Because back in the day pretty much only royalty got gout.

Jared Leto needed to gain a bunch of weight for a role so he gorged himself on carbs and got gout. When he cut out the carbs the gout went away.

Replies

32

I joke but the issue with modern medicine is that the massive groundbreaking humane advancements (antibiotics, safe general anesthesia making all types of surgery possible, MRI/CT/angiography revolutionizing radiology, typed and crossmatched blood transfusions) are always overshadowed by infinite quackery

Great roundup of medical advancements.

> overshadowed by infinite quackery

With the exception of computer science, all science is like this.

You've got people like Robert Maxwell intentionally trying to make things worse - but then you also have these supposed "scientists" who are total princesses and throw a bitch fit if someone finds an experiment that doesn't fit their grand theory. And then the universities and research centers do not fund great scientists, they fund great politicians who theater play as scientists.

The only reason I think CS manages to not get drowned in bullshit is because it's code, and when you send someone your code, they run it, and if it doesn't work, everybody knows instantly.
There's a little book called Quantised Accelerations, and in it the author proposes a new - fairly rough - theory about what might be causing inertial force.

But the majority of this little book is just one experiment after another that have been done before, have been reproduced, and yet cannot be explained by mainstream physics.

Now this is fine, it's okay have unknowns, but the fact that these things are NOT taught in school, and the physics community has decided to kind of pretend they don't exist, makes it impossible to take anyone in academia the slightest bit seriously.

And this is physics, supposedly the MOST serious branch of academia - and even they are acting like they can make facts go away by pretending they don't exist.

If I was king, I'd send a copy of this book to the dean of every university - along with the letter saying they're being defunded, effective immediately.
Yes, and there's a "reproducibility crisis" these days (lots of papers are basically made up)...

But there's another side of it which is "debunkers", and you're never gonna get a positive result out of one of these people because they're never gonna try to do the experiment right.

> Can not reproduce
> Okay buddy, tell it to your wife
So someday even psychiatry may be a respectable field?

I jest but I knew a young psychiatrist once who was beyond frustrated at not being able to help the truly ill patients she had to treat. Not the other ones. The genuinely ill. She'd joke that she should have gone into orthopedics.
Most doctors are basically ChatGPT but worse.

The whole field has been proceduralized to the point that you're not actually supposed to bring any unique knowledge, just match description to what's written in books. That's something which an AI is insanely good at.
I put a lot of blame on insurance companies for this. Infectious disease specialists have to regularly fight to get non-standard treatments done. I’ve heard stories where doctors will have to say to insurance companies reps stuff like this:
>So this js a recorded line, right? Okay good. Since you’re denying the life saving care that my patient needs, I just want to hear you say that you are the one making the medical decisions and functionally practicing medicine, so that when the wrongful death lawsuit hits it comes to you. Oh really? You won’t say that? You won’t practice medicine without a license? Okay, let’s talk to your boss then!”
on and on for two hours until they finally get approval. It’s insane.
> wrongful death lawsuit

Well that's part of it too, you can't wave the right to sue a doctor - and in a lot of cases, suing them is basically just second-guessing their decision.

So doctors can't make any decision that doesn't have the support of The Scientific Community, and they always have to recommend more tests, more specialists and more drugs at all times.

If they say "you're fine" and then you die, your family is gonna take their house - but if they say "oh you really need this pill" and you take it and die, then as long as their diagnosis was at least plausible, it's on the drug company, and suing the drug company is lolimpossible so the doctor is protected.

Forget where I heard it (maybe from Dark Enlightenment) but a strong argument can be made that sewage engineers saved far more lives than doctors since the start of the 20th century. Cities used to quite literally be shit holes

bro 100%. It’s hard for me to put to words, because I do think modern medicine is incredible, but it seems like they β€œoveract” sometimes. Most healing comes from getting homeostasis back and letting the body do its thing. Sometimes
that’s β€œimpossible” (is it though?), and that’s when things go off the rails. I started getting into chiropractors and naturopathic stuff a few years ago after doctors couldn’t diagnose an injury that an LMT detected (hip/glute) while working on my neck. Nobody even thought to check for fascia issue while I had two doctors and two nurses fondling my balls looking for a hernia.
When you realize Obesity, Type 2 diabetes, Heart attack (and high blood pressure & hardening of the arteries), cancer, PCOS, dental caries, Alzhiemers (sp), and a few other things are considered metabolic diseases (diseases of catmrbohydrates) it really changes the picture.

And several dr/profs have studied hunter gatherers do not get these things
All my reading and thinking has led me back to homeostasis as foundational truth of health (at least).

Focusing on homostasis as prime importance means taking away things that prevent health is number one. Over-eating? bad food? bad sleep? too much sedentary time? too much blue light? stale air? corrupted water? Too many "suppliments"?

it takes the focus away from the germ or the faulty gene or nucleotide and puts the onus upon the person, returning the power and responsibility into their own hands rather than a medical priest.

This philosopy pre-supposes that the body naturally knows how to be healthy.